Penname: SandraDee [Contact] Real name: Sandra
Member Since: 06 Jun 2008
Membership status: Member
Bio:

Beta-reader: Yes
Gender: female
Location: USA
Expertise In: water heater repair and proper techniques for bribing horses
[Report This]
Reviews by SandraDee
Rise and Fall by Penny Lane Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 2]
Summary:

They hold the land in their grasp.


Categories: General
Characters: None
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Alternate Universe, Romance
Series: Romance of the Absurd
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 4761 Read Count: 14271
[Report This] Published: 12 Oct 2009 Updated: 12 Oct 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 17 Oct 2009 Title: Chapter 1: Rise and Fall

Penny,

You have really outdone yourself!  What a superb installment to your Romance of the Absurd series! 

I was taken by how seemingly insignificant objects--the necklace and the baby doll--played such important roles in Skylar's turning points.  I was fascinated how the blood on the necklace signified the change in course of Skylar's life to one of a life of violence and crime.  Alternately, the baby doll represented a return to innocence, or some facsimile.  It's strange how objects can cast a spotlight on actions, but it happens in real life, too. 

Speaking of actions, I was fascinated to see the choices that Skylar had made.  From the Dale/Heather story earlier in your RotA series, I wondered what had become of Skylar, so I was excited to get the opportunity to find out.

Thank you for sharing this story with us!



Author's Response:

Thanks, Sandra!

I enjoyed writing this different kind of piece, a departure in a way, at least from how I have written Skylar before.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Sunday April Twenty-Third by Penny Lane Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 14]
Summary:

Some things can't stay forgotten.


Categories: Eric/Mary, Green Family, Holidays > Halloween
Characters: April Green, Emily Sullivan, Eric Green, Gail Green, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Johnston Green, Kenchy Dhuwalia, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: 1.19 - Casus Belli, 1.22 - Why We Fight
Genres: Humor
Series: None
Chapters: 7 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 64403 Read Count: 256082
[Report This] Published: 23 Oct 2009 Updated: 02 Feb 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 24 Oct 2009 Title: Chapter 1: Ghost Stories

PennyLane, you have me intrigued!  What an interesting start to this story!  I am eager to discover what the locket foretold.  I really like how you wove that mystery into the fabric of what we saw on the show and made it seem like a natural extension. 

I also enjoyed the stories that Johnston and Mary told back and forth.  Coming from a large family with the occasional eccentric, I could relate to the Aunt Milly story all too well!  Nice job seguing the storytelling into Mary's revelation that she had seen a ghostly figure.  Since it's not April, my mind is absolutely racing as to who or what it could be. 

I'm looking forward to finding out!



Author's Response:

Thanks, Sandra!

I've had a lot of fun with this story, not only with the somewhat zany holiday aspects but because I got to work with a bunch of characters I like writing. In this part, I got to write Johnston, which I don't often do, and I got to revisit a scene I really like from canon.

I do not have an Aunt Milly myself, but I have a large family too, and always pay attention during storytelling sessions. They're usually more entertaining than most scripted comedies I see.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 2: A Family Background

I enjoyed the backstory you provided for the siblings.  Though Sunday is horribly misguided, I can't help but feel for her somewhat.  As an adult, she has made choices, yes, but as a child, choices were made for her, choices that influenced the person she became and her ability to cope with her insecurities.  I was still rooting for April, of course, but you've done a nice job delving into both characters' psyches.

I also enjoyed the snippets of humor.  Just today, I rewatched the last episode of Jericho from season 1 that has the flashback to the Eric/April wedding.  I caught Jake's joke about April and Shep kissing, and when I read this, I like how you wove that into the fabric of the story and the characters' situations. 

On an entirely different note, I like the whimsical tone this story has.  Much like Pushing Daisies, as you noted at the beginning.  Penny Lane, I applaud you for your willingness to try different stylistic choices.  Heck, not just try them but your ability to make them work.  Kudos to you!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 3: The Haunting of Eric Green

This was an interesting chapter.  Eric, who is generally considered a voice of reason to some of the more exciteable characters around him, seeking out others' thoughts on the existence of ghosts...priceless.

I thought you did a really nice job capturing character voices.  Each reacted/said much like I would've thought based on what we've known of them. Yet their reactions were not passe or predictable. Not sure if I just made much sense there. LOL.

 Stanley's reaction was, by far, my favorite though:

"Ghosts?" asked Stanley. "The kind that slime people and leave a trail of ectoplasm?"

So funny! 

Of course, Eric's situation is no laughing matter, though I certainly do enjoy dramatic irony.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 4: Return of the Twin

Poor Kenchy!  I remember how traumatized he was after Rogue River and how he'd not wanted to operate on April.  Now to be faced with her doppleganger...yikes. 

I liked how you filled in the gaps, telling Sunday's perspective of the events we saw in the first installment of this story, learning more about her motivations, and how people are reacting to glimpses of April's "ghost."  I'm curious to see what happens with Sunday when she's discovered, as I'm nearly sure she'll eventually be known for who she is. 

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 5: The Games Begin

What a nice installment!  I loved the camaradie I saw in this chapter.  The Mary/Mimi conversation was especially good and did a nice job of highlighting their friendship.  Of course, the discussion in the living room about favorite candies and Halloween costumes had me in stitches.  I had so many images in my mind of these characters, at various ages, in these costumes. 

The ending was quite ominous.  Let the games begin, indeed! 

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 6: Lightning Round

Wow!  A couple of nice shockers in here.  I totally didn't see the real ghost of April coming back to help Mary (though I am pleased that April's doing so well), nor did I anticipate that Heather's guest would be Twenty-Third.  When she mentioned "T," I guess my mind went to Ted Lewis.  Nice job with the suprises!

And the fight...too funny.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 03 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 7: The Dust Settles

Once again, I love how you've tied the different threads of the mystery together.  You also managed to capture many moods here.  This chapter (like the story) has had its whimsical, humorous moments, but there's an underlying sense of heart. 

And, of course, this cracked me up:

“What do you mean?” she asked. A general furor of questioning had rustled across the room as well, and from the look on Jake's face, it was obvious his plans for Sunday hadn't involved beginning with therapy.

I could picture that look on Jake's face all too well. 

Nicely done!

Fleeting by Penny Lane Rated: K (Suitable for Most Ages) [Reviews - 2]
Summary:

They find each other in moments passing.


Categories: General
Characters: None
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Alternate Universe, Romance
Series: Romance of the Absurd
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 3435 Read Count: 13095
[Report This] Published: 11 Dec 2009 Updated: 11 Dec 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 13 Dec 2009 Title: Chapter 1: Fleeting

Oh wow!  This was fabulous, Penny Lane!  I am always eager to see which characters are paired in your Romance of the Absurd series, and I have to say that I wasn't expecting these two.  Of course, that is the point. LOL.  But you really made it work, this one-sided romance, born on the fleeting moments of the past.  The wistfulness from Oliver jumps off the page, but so does the image--his image--of a young Gail. 

I thought you stayed so true in your characterizations.  Oliver, the recluse, longs to interact with the vibrant red-head but can never entirely overcome his insecurities, the insecurities that overtake him as his life continues. 

I also enjoyed the glimpses into Gail and Johnston's courtship, the allusion to his mother's disapproval, and the images of Gail as a young mother.

What a bittersweet and beautiful vignette!



Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

This unique pairing was actually suggested by Skyrose, and it, of course, surprised me at first, but it inspired me too. I enjoyed delving into Oliver`s mind and life experience, and it was also fun to take a different look at Gail and her life than I ever had before.

As always, thanks for the feedback and the compliments. You made my day!

The Seagull and the Hawk by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 3]
Summary:

They hold on for as long as they can.


Categories: General
Characters: None
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Alternate Universe, Romance
Series: Romance of the Absurd
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 4876 Read Count: 12092
[Report This] Published: 06 Jan 2010 Updated: 06 Jan 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 01 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 1: The Seagull and the Hawk

PennyLane, you are so good at showing the inner workings of characters.  I particularly enjoyed your insight into the contrast between perception and reality where Maggie was concerned.  I feel for Bill--for losing the woman he loves, for losing their child, for that empty part of his life that Maggie's presence filled.  I feel for Maggie, as well, as she strives to find her place in a world that has never been particularly kind but is even less so now.

I can say so many good things about your stories, but one of the qualities that I like best is that they always make me think.

Thank you for sharing this with us!

Love is Blind but Jake Sure Isn't by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 3]
Summary:

It's hard to think rationally in a world gone mad.


Categories: General
Characters: None
Episode/Spoilers For: 1.13 - Black Jack
Genres: Parody/Satire
Challenges: Black Jack Challenge # 4
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 2464 Read Count: 14149
[Report This] Published: 12 Feb 2010 Updated: 12 Feb 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 16 Feb 2010 Title: Chapter 1: Love is Blind but Jake Sure Isn't

Oh, I loved this!  I think you've managed to do the impossible:  poke fun at the characters and exaggerate them while still keeping them in character. 

I'm not even sure where to really start with this, so I think I'll start with the title.  Jake Green might be able to see what's going on around him.  It might even be making him slightly nauseated and alternately wishing he could have someone, as well.  Yet I have to think the title is somewhat ironic.  Jake is blind.  Doesn't he know the old cliche that opposites attract?  Sure he doesn't like light beer, crossword puzzles, or flannel pajamas; but all the couples he, in some way, consulted or observed were opposites.  Opposites that complemented one another, the way he and Heather could if he'd not blown that.

Loved the running bits of humor.  For example, how the world is literally falling down around them, but they're all taking time out to work on their love lives.

And this:

"So, what's on your mind, Jake Green?" asked Mimi, ever the blunt one. She peered across the table at him with a piercing gaze. "You look like you're trying to sort out the origin of the universe or something."

Stanley shot Mimi a warning look, that was probably intended to signal 'No one ever pushes Jake Green when it comes to deep thinking' but Jake didn't feel like keeping up pretenses of happiness tonight, while happy couples danced and kissed and had a grand old time in front of him.

Simply cracked me up!  I mean, Jake is so frequently brooding/or presented as engaging in deep thinking in fanfiction, it was funny to see Mimi comment on it and in such a wickedly sarcastic way.

Last, but not least, I can't pass up commenting on Skylar and Dale.  Good thing Jake rescued them from their shenanigans of drinking (gasp) light beer.

So I guess with all my rambling, what I'm trying to get at is that I really liked this and thought it was clever how you managed to interpret the challenge prompt in such a unique and enjoyable way.

Thanks for sharing this with us!

Entwined by Penny Lane Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 1]
Summary:

They awaken in a changing world.


Categories: General
Characters: None
Episode/Spoilers For: 2.04 - Oversight, 2.07 - Patriots and Tyrants
Genres: Alternate Universe, Romance
Series: Romance of the Absurd
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 15578 Read Count: 19743
[Report This] Published: 08 Mar 2010 Updated: 08 Mar 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 15 Apr 2010 Title: Chapter 1: Entwined

What a lovely and poignant story, Penny Lane.  You did such a good job with building the relationship between these two characters that I really could, in my mind's eye, see it develop. 

Compass by wittlewawa Rated: K (Suitable for Most Ages) [Reviews - 2]
Summary:

This story takes place directly after the military occupation. The story will not follow canon, but I will be trying to keep with the characters as much as possible.


Categories: Jake/Heather
Characters: Eric Green
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Romance
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 824 Read Count: 13625
[Report This] Published: 09 May 2010 Updated: 09 May 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 13 May 2010 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This is a nice start.  It'll be interesting to see if Jake will put to good use these things he's realized about himself and Heather. Looking forward to reading more. :)

The Watch by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 2]
Summary:

A few Christmases after the bombs, they take time out of the evening to wait for an old friend. 


Categories: Holidays > Christmas
Characters: Eric Green, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Mary Bailey
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Drama
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 3813 Read Count: 16775
[Report This] Published: 29 Dec 2010 Updated: 29 Dec 2010
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 10 Jan 2011 Title: Chapter 1: The Watch

PennyLane, I really enjoyed getting this glimpse into the characters' past Christmases, as well as what their lives are like now.  Great imagery throughout. I also thought it was a nice touch that "the watch" was not for some disaster or enemy invader but for Stanley's arrival so they could continue a Christmas tradition for their children, albeit in a different way.

Thanks for sharing this with us!