Penname: SandraDee [Contact] Real name: Sandra
Member Since: 06 Jun 2008
Membership status: Member
Bio:

Beta-reader: Yes
Gender: female
Location: USA
Expertise In: water heater repair and proper techniques for bribing horses
[Report This]
Reviews by SandraDee
Once Removed by Penny Lane Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 35]
Summary:

A dark and lonely road, a vehicular crash, a world he'd never dreamt of.


Categories: General
Characters: April Green, Bill, Bonnie Richmond, Dale Turner, Emily Sullivan, Eric Green, Gail Green, Gray Anderson, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Jimmy Taylor, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Sean Henthorn, Skylar Stevens, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: Season 1, Season 2
Genres: Drama
Series: None
Chapters: 10 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 29853 Read Count: 443767
[Report This] Published: 09 Oct 2008 Updated: 21 Jan 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 04 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 8: Part Eight: The Empty Rabbit Hole and the Unusual Suspect

Wow!  Just when I think I know what's going to happen, you throw an absolute curveball.  I love how you keep me guessing, Penny! 




Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

I've enjoyed getting to write a little mystery in this story, since I haven't done a lot of multi-chaptered stories before.

 

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 17 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 9: Part Nine: Hell Breaks Loose

What an intense chapter, Penny!  It gave me chills.  You created such imagery with your words, as well as intense emotions, it was like I was watching it all unfold.

I guess it goes to show that for as bad as their situation was, it could always get worse.  My heart absolutely went out to the people being "evacuated."  The panic they felt, the uncertainty, the separation from loved ones was almost palpable. 

So now Jake is awake from his vision.  I wonder what he's going to do now that he's back?  I can hardly wait to see what you have in store for us!




Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

This chapter was difficult to write in some ways, but quite easy to get into, once I committed to the emotions and atmosphere such a scene would inspire in the characters.

Each character faces a tragic moment in this part, I believe, and you're right, it could always get worse for them.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 04 Feb 2009 Title: Chapter 10: Part Ten: As Daylight Breaks

What a fabulous conclusion, Penny Lane. I loved absolutely all of it, though I have to confess that the ending literally brought tears to my eyes. You have such a way with words, and your story is so beautifully crafted.  Thank you for sharing it with us!




Author's Response:

Thank you for the wonderful comments!

I enjoyed writing this story, with all its emotional moments and tragic turns. It was challenging, in a good way, and I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for going along for the ride!

Ghost Town by Marzee Doats, Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 4]
[Report This] Published: 18 Oct 2008 Updated: 18 Oct 2008
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 18 Oct 2008 Title: Chapter 1: Ghost Town

Oh my goodness!  This was soooo hysterical.  I literally sat here hee-hawing out loud with tears running down my cheeks.  Scared my poor little puppy in the process, too!

This was *just* what I needed! I was trying to decide which epitaph was my favorite, and it's hard to choose, but I really liked Gray Anderson's two-sided stone.  Then again, the death by peroxide fumes of Jonah Prowse was wickedly funny as well.  And Vanilla Ice? LOL.

Loved the nod-nod-wink-wink of just who the historians were. 

Thanks for the laughs, gals!




Author's Response:

Our apologies to your puppy, Sandra!  We're glad you enjoyed our little foray into insanity.  We couldn't pick just one epitaph for Gray, and really, how can we not be expected to comment on Emily's hair color?

My thanks to Penny for coming up with the initial list for my entertainment.  It all snowballed from there. :-D

-- Marzee

True North by mainemom Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 1]
Summary:

Jake and Heather find out that they are no longer all that different from each other.


Categories: Jake/Heather
Characters: Heather Lisinski, Jake Green
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: Romance
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 4199 Read Count: 19555
[Report This] Published: 18 Dec 2008 Updated: 18 Dec 2008
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 18 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 1: The Cabin

I thought this was a really nice start to your story.  This line really struck me:

For two people who had seemed so different just a couple of years before they now had become more similar than he would have liked.

If anyone can understand what Heather's going through, it's definitely Jake.  I look forward to seeing how he helps her find her true north.

Four Facts and a Match Among Friends by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 8]
Summary:

The facts were simple. The times were not. And the Greens were owed a rematch.


Categories: Green Family, Hawkins Family, Richmond Family, Holidays > Thanksgiving
Characters: Allison Hawkins, Darcy Hawkins, EJ Green, Eric Green, Gail Green, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Johnston Green, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Robert Hawkins, Sam Hawkins, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: 2.07 - Patriots and Tyrants, Season 1, Season 2
Genres: Drama, Humor
Series: None
Chapters: 5 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 15561 Read Count: 133001
[Report This] Published: 25 Nov 2008 Updated: 27 Nov 2008
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 07 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 1: Waiting

Oh, Penny, it was so nice to have Johnston back.  Reading this first part was, I have to admit, a little bittersweet, knowing what we do about the characters--that Jake would be estranged from his father for years, that Eric and April would get married but end up apart, and that Johnston would meet his end in battle quite different from the game of football.

I think my favorite part was the end, though, with Gail and Johnston enjoying each other's company.  I always enjoyed watching them on the show because of their obvious rapport, their connection, and their understanding of each other.  I thought you did a great job capturing them.

And let me just say kudos to Kara.  Like her, I don't get why Jake and Emily continue this back and forth. 




Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

I really enjoyed writing this scene from Green family Thanksgivings-past. It definitely did end up bittersweet, with all the things that will change in the future, including the relationships within this family.

I liked writing Johnston, a character I don't get to explore often, and it was really fun getting to go into his relationship with Gail, something else I don't often do.

Kara liked to state her opinions, to the chagrin of some family members, though I suppose she was proven right in the end of this one, if you read on.

 

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 07 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 2: Waking

Such a beautiful chapter, Penny.  I think yours is the first story I've seen deal with the direct aftermath of Stanley and Mimi's graveside vows.  You are so good at relating a multitude of emotions and reactions. 

Thank you for sharing this with us!




Author's Response:

Thank you!

Stanley and Mimi's graveside vows really touched me, more than almost any other scene in season two, or the whole series possibly. Certainly it was one of the more hopeful, moving scenes, in my humble opinion. It seemed natural to go from there when thinking of what Mimi is most grateful for in her life.

Thanks again!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 08 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 3: Wondering

Oh, Penny, no one could capture those quiet moments quite like you do.   You always amaze me with your creativity, the way your words weave a picture, and how you can make the ordinary--talking on the phone at Thanksgiving--seem extraordinary.

This is the first story I've ever seen in which Allison is the main voice.  What an interesting choice!   Her thoughts on essentially being torn between what she wanted and what she needed really got to me. Many people have that choice to make.  At the same time, it's a good reminder that the world is vastly changed, even all these years later. 

I'll be interested in seeing whether the public face remains intact for Hawkins or if he's comfortable enough to show his private face with the Greens at the upcoming ball game.  I imagine that in some ways, that private vs. public face extends to Allison, as well.  She is most certainly her father's daughter, bound by obligation, duty, and yet also fiercely loyal to those she cares about. 

Thanks for sharing your story with us!




Author's Response:

Thank you for the wonderful compliments!

I loved getting to explore Allison for the first time here. I think she's a fascinating character. I think your observations about Hawkins and his private face, and how Allison takes after him in that way, are spot on.

 

The Carol by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 12]
Summary: Past Featured Story

Dale has a haunting dream one December night.


Categories: Holidays > Christmas
Characters: Allison Hawkins, April Green, Bonnie Richmond, Dale Turner, Emily Sullivan, Eric Green, Gail Green, Gracie Leigh, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Jimmy Taylor, Johnston Green, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Sean Henthorn, Skylar Stevens, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: Season 1
Genres: Alternate Universe
Series: None
Chapters: 6 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 31857 Read Count: 253735
[Report This] Published: 01 Dec 2008 Updated: 24 Dec 2008
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 02 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 1: Part One: A Familiar Face

Ah, Penny, I love it!  Though inspired by the Dickens classic, you've certainly made this your own and captured the characters from Jericho and their situations.  As always, your attention to detail is second to none.  For instance, Gracie Leigh's chains--which consisted of the trinkets she traded for, along with the pesiticide--were both humorous and appropriate.  Dale's certainty that his seeing Gracie is the result of parasites or irradiated seeds in the oatmeal he ate was a great homage to Scrooge's certainty that his vision was the result of a bad meal (undercooked potatos in ACC?  Don't remember exactly).

I'm really looking forward to going through this journey with Dale!




Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

I just love A Christmas Carol, so I had a great time adapting it to another fictional world I love. I had to look it up myself, what food Scrooge blamed in the original, because I was remembering 'a glob of mustard'. Turns out we are both right, he blames potatos, mustard, meat and cheese. Poor Dale only had mushy oatmeal.

Thanks so much for taking time to read and review, and I hope you enjoy the next spirit's visit!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 18 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 2: Part Two: The First Spirit

Oh, Penny, you've done such a good job with this story!  I can see why it would be painful for Dale to look back, albeit for differing reasons.

The scene with his mother--Dale's mom not being able to provide the presents she wanted but them managing to have fun anyway--really struck me as an amazing contrast to Dale's current situation.  Compared to most in Jericho, he's rich materially.  Yet he's obviously lacking in what truly matters--the love of family.

The scene with Dale being in Emily's classroom had me alternately chuckling (Sean playing hangman...it's a wonder that boy knows how to spell anything other than vibe) and feeling for him. The awkwardness that Dale felt, the terror, and (what I perceived to be) excitement over being noticed by the teacher seemed painstakingly real. It was obviously uncomfortable for Scroogish-Dale, but I couldn't quite decide why.  Was it because Dale was seeing the boy he used to be?  The one who was meek, the one that few noticed? 

I also enjoyed the scene with Skylar and Dale and the contraband Christmas tree.  It definitely has me wondering what happened to estrange the two . I can only assume they are estranged or that something bad happened to Skylar.  Otherwise, the I'd say that the two would be spending the holiday season together, and we'd have a more jovial Dale who would likely not be in need of a visit from Christmas spirits. 

I look forward to finding out more!




Author's Response:

Thanks!

You're very right about the contrast between Dale's situations in Christmas past and present. He's gained one thing he once seemed to be lacking, but lost something that is more important.

Scroogish Dale did find it uncomfortable to see himself in Emily's class, I think for the reasons you stated. It's hard to see himself so vulnerable, when he's tried so hard to build an armour around himself.

You are also right about Skylar/Dale, in that this scene from the past, and the change in their dynamic in the present, has affected Dale very much this Christmas.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 31 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 3: Part Three: The Second Spirit

Another enjoyable installment, Penny. 

Like Dale, I felt like I was eavesdropping on some very interesting conversations.  I enjoyed getting snapshots of what life is like for Jericho's citizens along with Dale.  It couldn't have been easy for him to be the butt of jokes or the subject of scoffing. Then again, I suppose he has earned it.

I also liked how you chose Johnston to be the second ghost.  It was a fitting choice.

I'm off to read more!




Author's Response:

Thanks!

This was one of the chapters I had the most fun writing. It was certainly eye opening for Dale, but kind of karmic, as you said.  

Johnston as the second ghost was one of my first 'casting' ideas when I decided I was going to write this. His philosophy seemed perfect for the ghost of post-apocalyptic Christmas Present.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 02 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 4: Part Four: The Third Spirit

How perfect was that ending and the reveal of the third spirit!?!  When the men were lamenting the unfairness of Dale's murder and saying he never killed anyone, I thought to myself, 'Little do they know.... '  So that got me thinking about Mitch Cafferty and wondering if he would fit into the tale in some way.  I guess I got my answer.

Being familiar with Dickens's tale, I knew that Dale would eventually realize the identity of the murdered man; nevertheless, I found myself in suspense as Dale went on this journey of discovery.  I enjoyed reading the twists and turns of this discovery.  You do such a good job with characterization, Penny.  I just love reading your work!




Author's Response:

Thanks for the great compliments!

I enjoyed playing with the mysterious and creepy spirit here, and I was lucky as I had the perfect spirit to haunt Dale in his future. It was fun to use the irony of what his workers didn't know in the scene whre they discussed Dale's murder and whether he had ever killed anyone.

It was fun exploring Dale's character through this story, and I had a lot to work with. Thanks for reading!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 02 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 5: Part Five: Christmas Day

Another satisfying part to the story, Penny!  I really liked how you tied together these snippets of events that Dale had observed into the changes Dale made in the lives of others and in his own attitude.  It was also good to see Dale stop cutting himself off and reconnect with humanity.




Author's Response:

Thanks, Sandra!

Poor Dale went through so much in that one night, he needed to enjoy this day, and I think he had to reconnect with his fellow survivors and his own humanity to do that. It was lots of fun to write, and thanks for going along for the ride!

Winter's Light by Penny Lane Rated: K+ (Some Content May Not be Suitable for Young Children) [Reviews - 4]
Summary: Past Featured Story

Facing the second Christmas after the world's end, the people of Jericho, Kansas look for the light.


Categories: Richmond Family, Holidays > Christmas, Dale/Skylar, Eric/Mary, Stanley/Mimi, Green Family, Hawkins Family
Characters: Allison Hawkins, Bill, Bonnie Richmond, Dale Turner, Darcy Hawkins, Eric Green, Gail Green, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Jimmy Taylor, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Robert Hawkins, Russell, Sam Hawkins, Sean Henthorn, Skylar Stevens, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: None
Genres: None
Series: None
Chapters: 2 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 18081 Read Count: 41016
[Report This] Published: 24 Dec 2008 Updated: 07 Jan 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 19 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 1: Christmas Eve

What a lovely beginning, Penny.  This story strikes me as wistful.   Perhaps its beginning with Allison Hawkins longing for something as ordinary as her ice skates--long since obliterated--which is in essence a longing for life as she once knew it that, grabbed me.  Then there are the townspeople, carrying on the best way they can to make Christmas a special occassion in a post-Apocalyptic world with fewer resources and a greater appreciation for what they do have. 

Little Hailey, a child who has obviously been through a great deal more than any little one should have to, really struck me.  I enjoyed how Skylar, once a character that I considered so inane, tried to relate with her through the snow angel.

Things have changed, indeed, as seen from Sean Henthorn being a (gasp) contributing member of the community. 

Yet an interesting contrast to the wistfulness of this installment is the good cheer of the Taylor household and how, despite the weight that seems to be on everyone's shoulders, they manage to find joy even in adversity.  What a perfect Santa Jimmy would make!  I wonder who will take his place now that his back is out.

I'm off to read more!




Author's Response:

Thanks Sandra!

I definitely wanted to hit a few notes with this holiday story, and I wanted it to be hopeful but realistic. I was especially interested in how people would try to celebrate, and keep going, through holidays during such difficult times. I think it's something that happens to most of us at some point, having to do holidays differently when things in our lives change, sometimes for the worse, and figure out how to remain hopeful, and of course, the people of Jericho are experiencing that challenge on a much grander scale. But I think because they've lost so much, as you said, they have a much greater understanding and appreciation for the important things that they do still have.

I liked writing a Sean who grew, from the 'vibe' guy we once knew, and I really enjoy writing Skylar. I think she's a great dynamic character.

Poor Jimmy was really looking forward to playing Santa and spreading his good cheer around. I guess he'll get to do it the next year.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 19 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 2: Christmas Day

Penny, you do such a good job with making the characters so real. 

I read through this chapter a couple of times, and both times, I got a lump in my throat with the beginning--Stanley's Christmas morning memories and the new memories he is making with Mimi.  The loss of Bonnie is so palpable, and I feel it all the more through the details you provide of their past.  When I think of what Stanley has been through, my heart just breaks for him.

On a lighter note, I enjoyed the preparations for the Christmas party, the treasured chocolate, the pilfering of crayons from the church (overabundance of yellow not withstanding).  Naturally, the relationship between Jake and Heather was interesting to me, that they fall into an easy rapport when they are on the road with Hawkins but don't particularly spend much time together while in Jericho.  The mention of Jake being aware that he is constantly watched made me wonder if that had anything to do with it and maybe he feels like he has to put on a certain appearance.  Yet their situation also rings true.  I've had friendships in the past similar to what Jake and Heather have going on here.

The transmission had me absolutely riveted, as it did the occupants of Bailey's.  It must almost seem like a disembodied voice coming to them.  They have been cut off for so long, fending for themselves, fighting their own battles (literally), the address from the president must be disconcerting.  I imagine it would raise all kinds of questions in their minds, this message of hope. 

As always, you leave me wanting more.  Thank you for sharing your story with us.




Author's Response:

Thank you!

I'm really fond of so many of the Jericho characters so I loved having a chance to write about a bunch of them in this story.

I find Stanley and Mimi's relationship especially fascinating and touching, so I really wanted to explore the sense of loss and hope they'd feel on this difficult Christmas. This was the first scene I wrote for this story, and so it kind of set the mood for everything else I wrote after.

I had fun writing about the Christmas party, pilfered crayons (inspired by the yellow-heavy crayon buckets of my childhood Sunday School), and the chocolate (that I think changed hands five times). I guess it's the little things sometimes, that can have meaning to us in these times. Heather and Jake are in an awkward, somewhat transitional phase of their friendship, and I don't think either has exactly figured it out yet.

The transmission was a challenge for me to write, but I really wanted to remind the characters of the outside world, and the outside problems they have to face. You're very right about how they will take this message, coming from this power that seems to have no affect on their daily lives.

Thanks for reading and commenting!

Auld Lang Syne by Marzee Doats, Penny Lane Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 8]
Summary: Feature

Out with the old and in with the new! Should auld acquaintance be forgot and never brought to mind? The countdown begins as the denizens of Jericho ring in the new year.


Categories: Stanley/Mimi, Holidays > New Years, Dale/Skylar, Eric/Mary
Characters: Allison Hawkins, Bill, Dale Turner, Darcy Hawkins, Emily Sullivan, Eric Green, Gail Green, Gray Anderson, Major Edward Beck, Mary Bailey, Mimi Clark, Robert Hawkins, Sam Hawkins, Sean Henthorn, Skylar Stevens, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: Season 2
Genres: Humor
Series: None
Chapters: 3 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 35170 Read Count: 86145
[Report This] Published: 30 Dec 2008 Updated: 28 Feb 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 30 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 1: A Problem

This was great!  I'll be back tomorrow with more detailed feedback, but for now, just let me say how much I enjoyed it. :)

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 31 Dec 2008 Title: Chapter 1: A Problem

I really enjoyed this first installment of Auld Lang Syne.  I'm such a fan of details that make the characters seem real.  The thoughts that Beck had about his family--particularly his daughter and her aversion to change--were alternately humorous.  Humorous because they were so true to what kids do and sad considering that Beck's family is lost to him.  This first part really helped to set the stage for his worsening condition as he considers all that is lost to him, thanks to a grainy, photocopied "newspaper" article written by a fifteen year old.

And as a Jake/Heather fan, let me just say how happy I am that they got married.  Heehee.  And is it bad of me to be glad that Beck and Emily suffered?  Well, if it is, I guess I'm bad.  Now, back to my thoughts on the chapter....

"You're married. Someone wanted to marry you. You get to live happily ever after. Even if it is with Eric Green." With a nod, as if she were approving such a match, Emily held up a dart. "Married to Eric! Mary married Eric! And when you had a bouquet to throw, you threw it at her! But what a surprise, you're one of them now, those oh-so-happy Greens! I should'a known you'd stick together. So you can't talk, about problems!"

I can't say that I was particularly surprised to see Emily wallow in self-pity.  The sad thing is that she has quite a bit to offer someone if she weren't so unpleasant to be around.  Her meltdown with Mary here had me cracking up.  Guess she thinks Eric is no prize. LOL.  Ironic considering that at the moment, Emily is not much of a prize, either. 

Oh, and I love how Mary wrestled the darts from Emily after a near miss of other tavern patrons. 

"She's drunk too!  Plus, she keeps trying to assassinate my customers with darts when she isn't busy spouting off anti-marriage rhetoric and being disgusted by post-bombs romance and vilifying the entire Green family.  And, she's got a copy of the paper, too, only she's drawn a mustache on Heather and horns and a tail on Jake."

LOL. I loved this!  So witty, so funny.

Actually, there were several lines that I absolutely heehawed over.  Mimi telling off Beck was another part that I enjoyed.

"You can stop crying over my friends' picture, stop creeping people out, and stop scaring away my friend's customers!"

And this was soooo something that I could see Stanley doing. 

"Why don't you just go back to your stupid happy wife and your stupid happy baby and your stupid happy life!" she spat.

Stanley blinked. For a moment it looked like he might become as irate as her, but instead, he smiled. "Think I will. Thanks. And you have a happy year."

Gray's pursuit of Gail--as well as Eric's seething over the mayor's interest and Gail tried to dodge her would-be suitor--also cracked me up.  Yet when Emily approached Gray to start something up with him, I just busted out laughing, particularly when Gray told her that his third wife insisted that he get fixed.  Muahahaha.

I love this.  It's outlandish, but it's quality outlandishness.  I'm looking forward to Mary, et al. trying to plan and carry out (what I assume is) a match between Beck and Emily, two losers--*clear throat*--losers in love, that is. 

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 28 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 2: A Plan

What an enjoyable story!  I had the chance to read it several days ago, but things have been so hectic with work that I’ve not had the opportunity to remark until now.

This installment was leg-slapping hilarious.  There’s nothing so fun as a little gentle mocking, and this story does a great job with pulling those quirks characters have, as well as the perceptions we have about the characters, and capitalizing on them. 

The Gail/Gray subplot was entertaining—if for nothing else than to see Eric squirm.

Of course, the bulk of the story related to the attempted matchmaking (with a cameo appearance by Mr. Stealth himself, Hawkins) of Emily and Beck.  I really enjoyed the lengths that the characters went to, and I found the dialogue to be so witty.

I’ve pulled out a few of my favorite parts:

Quote:

"So our goal is to make him," said Bill, grasping the pepper shaker in his hand, "think she's deep, and her," he held the salt shaker, "think he's sane."

And so the delicious irreverence begins.  I loved this.  And how perfect was it for these comments to come from Bill’s mouth?  He’s something of a contrarian/comic relief.

 

Quote:

"Jake and Heather's wedding was not anyone's fault," said Gail firmly. "It's not something anyone is going to blamed for. You don't blame people for something good! So let's just focus on our task at hand. The girls are going to talk to Emily. I know you can do it," she sent her daughter-in-law an encouraging smile. "And the boys are going to talk to him." She nodded her head in Beck's direction, wincing slightly as the army officer let out a long-drawn out sniffle.

Too funny!  That was my thought, too, so I was cheering on Gail.

 

Quote:

Eric shook his head, asking, "Team Yente?" Mary hid a smile.

Fiddler on the Roof?

As they embarked on their mission, it brought a smile to my face to see them trying to garner their courage and will to do what they didn’t particularly want to do but what would be the least of all evils.

 

Quote:

"They say they'll call and they don't, they say they'll feed your fish while you're in Mexico with your mom and you find them dead when you get back," proclaimed Mimi.

"They forget your birthday or they say you're the best and then they write it on the locker room wall," sighed Mary.

"They shut your dress in the car door or they dump you for your best friend," added Emily.

I loved how you wrote this, that each of the women in the process of dishing men, revealed something very much in keeping with their personalities.  Granted, with this being a satire, it’s a caricatured version, but it’s the little details like this that make this story one of quality.

 

Quote:

As Emily regained her balance, Mimi leaned in to whisper, "You know, I'd resent that but I agree with part of her assessment. She really has plowed through the available choices in this town."

LOL.  Yeah, let’s see.  Jake, Roger, an attempt at Gray.  It’s true that Emily’s choices are severely limited.

Quote:

The three men pretended to scoff in disbelief. "You can. You once commanded a whole company! You were a leader. You can take charge again," said Eric, clarifying quickly, "Of your own life, I mean."

I think it’s a good thing that I wasn’t drinking something when I read this.  I would have been spewing liquid all over my computer!  Of course, the funniest part to me was Eric’s addendum.  Yes, Eric, please don’t give Beck any ideas of leading other people again.  Yikes.  We know how well that turned out last time.

 

Quote:

Emily seemed torn between amusement and suspicion. "Beck? The army man? The one you held secret meetings to talk about behind his back?"

"He was doing his job, I was doing mine," shrugged Mary, quickly searching for a way to further commit to her role. She hopped onto the stool beside Emily, swiveling to look at the Major. "He's  a man in uniform. That's something."

Mimi had stepped towards the bar between them, leaning her elbow against it, one hand on her stomach. "He's strong. He's seen the world."

"Maybe," said Emily, her tone still indicating disbelief.

"Oh, come on, look at him!" said Mary, hoping Emily would follow her instructions and not see the expression on her own face as she forced out her next words. "He's got that - that smoldering thing going on!"

Beck did indeed look like he was feeling something intense as he clutched at his chest and squinted his eyes.

"Told you that spinach dip was iffy," Mimi whispered into her friend's ear. Mary widened her eyes at Mimi, who quickly said out loud, "Yeah, what a hunk!"

Mary and Mimi make a dangerous team, don’t they?  They know just which strings to pull, and they’re playing Emily like she’s a marionette.  Human nature is fascinating.  Many people will claim that they don’t care what others think, when in truth, other people’s opinions are very important.  Well, Emily certainly has never claimed to be in the “I don’t care” camp.”  They’re smart to talk up Beck.  Maybe if Emily hears enough good things, she’ll believe them. 

The aside about the dip, though, was just priceless.

 

Quote:

"He really needs someone now. Think of how it'll feel, being needed. And then, when he lets you in, you can change him. You can help him be even better than he was before," Mary added.

Oh, yes, because women who go into relationships thinking they can change me are always so successful. ;)

 

Quote:

"You know what they say," Mary quickly picked up. "What you do when you get thrown off a horse."

"Sue the stables?" Mimi couldn't help whispering, adding "Yeah, you pick yourself up and get back on again!"

"But that's just it!" said Emily, seemingly pleased to finally discuss this with someone. "I can't get on again. She's taken my -"

"Not the same horse!" exclaimed Mary.

I loved this.  Cute exchange!

 

Quote:

"Yeah," agreed Mimi. "That's the whole beauty of surviving bombs, war, and disease. Live through it, you might find yourself someone you never even thought to look for before."

This was so tongue-in-cheek. If I were in their situation, I don’t think that I would have a sense of humor about it, but seeing how this is satirical in nature, I thought it was hilarious.

 

Quote:

"Come on man, say it with me. I am a strong, confident man. I am a strong, confident man," Bill repeated.

For some reason, I’m having visions of John Edwards standing in front of the mirror to comb his hair for a 10 minute stretch trying to get every last strand in the right place. 

Just the thought of Bill saying this like a mantra and attempting to give Beck a pep talk tickled my funny bone.


Quote:

Beck mused. "She looks familiar."

"Maybe because she's a contributing citizen often seen around town?" suggested Eric.

"She has a memorable mugshot?" came from Stanley.

LOL

 

Quote:

"And, she was one for following the rules if I ever did meet one. I can honestly say I never caught her in the hallway without a hall pass, not even once." Mrs. McVeigh nodded emphatically.

Stanley grinned as he whispered to Eric, "That's because she'd learned to forge every teacher's name by fourth grade!"

Oh goodness! Now they’re bringing in the big guns like Mrs. McVeigh and Sean!  The dichotomy between the Emily they present to Beck and the real Emily was amusing.  Wonder if/when Beck starts to find out about her, he’ll see the real her.

 

Quote:

"Mr. Hawkins, do you want to...dance?" asked Mary finally.

An amused look flashed over Hawkins' features as he took in her expression, and his eyes flitted over to the table that Mimi was subtly indicating.

"Don't you know he's married?" asked Emily, peering over her wine cooler to look at Mary. After a moment, she let out a laugh, throwing her head back. "Right, never mind."

Burn, Mary, burn!  This was one of the rare occasions when I found myself cheering on Emily.

 

Quote:

"And that's only one side to him," Mimi continued. "He's got a sensitive side too. I remember back from that time...This one day, I was sitting outside the med centre, crying and wondering what was going on and where everyone was, and the major came over to me. I was expecting another reasonable offer," she grinned at Mary, "But, he offered me a stick of Juicy Fruit. He can really be very thoughtful."

LOL.  I love the creativity here.

 

Quote:

"And you know, he really is a big teddy bear," broke in Stanley. "I heard from Jimmy, one time the major stopped the guys from driving their tank over a caterpillar -"

"She's saying something!"

"He's looking kind of mad."

"No, that's his intensely interested look," interjected Stanley.

With much prodding, it looks like the conspirators are going to get Emily and Beck to at least look at each other twice.  Here’s to hoping that when they do, it won’t end in a complete ruination of everyone’s New Year’s Eve.   Emily and Beck—well, they deserve each other.

Cute story!  I’m looking forward to reading what else you have in store for us.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 04 Mar 2009 Title: Chapter 3: A Pursuit

Oh boy!  It looks like Beck and Emily are taking the matchmaking of the others to heart!  What a funny chapter!  I'll be back this weekend to comment more fully, but just let me say for now that I enjoyed it very much. :)

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 08 Mar 2009 Title: Chapter 3: A Pursuit

So many funny details in this chapter.  Some of my favorite were

- Eric's declaration of imminent domain on the jukebox

- Grays' choice for a rather...um...unique gift for Gail

- Eric's EGG initials

- Emily alternately insulting her "friends" while also asking for their help in putting together a wedding

- the wedding reception snacks (jalapeno poppers and cream puffs...representative of the bride and groom, anyone?)

So, will our blissfully drunk couple actually go through with the nuptials?  Will each finally get what s/he deserves?  I look forward to finding out. :)

 

Different Circumstances, Part 13 by Marzee Doats Rated: T (Contains Content Not Suitable for Children) [Reviews - 23]
Summary:

What if circumstances were different, and Jake and Heather had met long before the school bus?  An alternate version of Jericho in which Jake and Heather are married and expecting.  A re-telling of the Jericho episode Heart of Winter.

 

 


Categories: Green Family, Jake/Heather
Characters: April Green, Eric Green, Gail Green, Heather Lisinski, Jake Green, Johnston Green, Mimi Clark, Stanley Richmond
Episode/Spoilers For: 1.14 - Heart of Winter
Genres: Alternate Universe, Drama, Romance
Series: Different Circumstances
Chapters: 5 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 47091 Read Count: 202911
[Report This] Published: 05 Jan 2009 Updated: 14 Jun 2009
Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 06 Jan 2009 Title: Chapter 1: Part 13A

Marzee, I loved, loved, loved this installment.  It was not at all easy to read (not from the standpoint of the impeccable writing but from the standpoint of imagining the characters growing desperation).  At the same time, I really felt like I was reading a story told with such painstaking quality--as I always feel when I read your work.  I really wish I could single out every single thing that I noticed, but then this review would be as long as your chapter!

Okay, enough general gushing.  I should get to the specifics.

First off, the present...

You did such a good job setting the stage for the worsening situation the characters are facing with your details.  Baron's release (which as someone who loves her dogs like children, that was soooo hard for me to read), the morbid hopefulness that perhaps one of the horses would have to be put down due to starvation, letting Christmas pass by with little mention, the lack of game for miles around, etc.  So I'm not sure if the lack of game was meant to be mysterious.  I figured that the game had been overhunted, but the characters' reactions left me feeling like there was more to it.

The effects of the slow starvation that the characters are experiencing--the lethargy, the short tempers--really had me concerned for them.  I know they aren't real people, but through your story, I feel like I've come to know them because you put so many touches into your story that help them come to life.  I can't help but wonder how they will make it through the winter, especially since it is just getting started.

Speaking of those not making it through the winter, I was shocked to read of Karen (Bitchmore) Harper's death.  Jimmy certainly does provide interesting information.  I can't say that I would mourn Karen (the way she treated Jake and Eric as their babysitter, as well as the condescension she showed Heather) certainly did not endear her to me anymore than she was endeared to the Greens.  Nevertheless, the tragic end does emphasize just how dire the situation is.

The evidence of mass migration that Stanley, Mimi, and Jake saw really stirred my imagination.  I wonder how badly Canada was affected by the attacks.  As weird as it sounds, wouldn't people from the Dakotas and Montana have been better off seeking refuge in Canada from the winter?  Yes, Canada is cold, but if its infrastructure is still in place....Of course, all of that is contigent on the circumstances in Canada.  While the U.S. does provide a whole heck of a lot of food to other countries, part of Canada is renowned for its agriculture, so one would think that Canada, if willing (which iit has historically been) to accept refugees would be a valid alternative to the trek south by foot.

Once again, as a dog person, I found the description of the pack of dogs--many of whom had been pets--to be disturbing.

You also touched upon some very interesting topics of a different nature:  The politics of the town, for instance, as well as imminent domain.  I can understand why Mary would complain loudly, but if she thinks the confiscation of 40 gallons of fuel was a violation of her civil rights, just wait until she meets the A.S.A.  Not surprisingly, she depended on Eric to make things better for her, but Eric is such a schmuck.  I also liked seeing how Johnston continues to wield some influence where the goings-on in town are concerned.  It's good to see that Gray will not go against the council, so that does make it easier to strings to be pulled behind the scenes, but it will be interesting to see if Gray will continue to submit to their wishes.

PAST

When I first read the description of Jake waking up with Heather, my immediate thought was not that they had slept together.  I halfway thought that Jake was dreaming that he was with Heather but that he would wake up with Baron in his bed instead. LOL.  I liked what you did better than what my first thought was, btw.

I love how you write Jake and Heather.  That flush of new love just feels good to read.  Naturally, I found Jake and E.J.'s conversation about putting Heather's reputation on the line to be interesting, particularly as some parallels were drawn to Emily.  I had to chuckle at the idea of Emily's mother having married up when she married Jonah.  The fact that people would forgive (or look the other way) certain behaviors of Emily but hold Heather in disdain for similar or even lesser behaviors also struck me as true.  I have a student who is an absolute stinker.  His classmates just saw, "That's how X is."  Whereas if another one of their classmates made similar comments, I guarantee you that there would be hell to pay.

Jake's off-handed solution that they get married brought a smile to my face at first, but then I thought about it, and realized that it was not the way to ask someone to get married.  (I don't have much to compare this to--I basically told my husband that we were getting married and that was that).  Looks like Heather agreed with me that it wasn't the type of proposal she wanted, either.

I was worried when she started to leave but was delighted that Jake chased her down--barefoot and nearly wiping out in the process, no less.  I have the feeling that he's going to get it right the second time around. :)

Thank you again for such a fabulous read!




Author's Response:

Sandra, thank you so much for your comments.  You're going to make me blush!  I truly appreciate them, though.  I always feel like I write too slow, but I don't know any other way to do it because I like to put in the details, and to figure out what everyone is thinking and feeling as they go through these experiences that are all unchartered territory.

I completely understand why reading about Baron and the pack of dogs Jake, Stanley and Mimi encounter would be hard.  I originally thought that Jake and Heather would naturally have a dog (and maybe a cat or two) but I wimped out way back at the beginning of writing this story because I didn't want to think about what would happen to their beloved pet.  Having to turn Baron out is a compromise with reality since I couldn't bring myself to have him hit by a car or put down. :-(  So hopefully neither of us will regret my bringing Baron into the story.  I can commit to him making it at least, as miraculous as that might be.

As for Karen Harper, I just couldn't imagine her making it too long in a world where all the rules had changed so drastically.  She was all about control, and she'd certainly lost a lot of it.  Unfortunately, taking her own life -- and her family's -- was a way for her to regain that control.  Still, Karen I'm sure will make her presence known again at some point in the past.

I absolutely agree that Canada would be a valid alternate destination, and have wondered about that myself.  I went with what the show showed us, but I do have to think that Canada would be willing to help.  If course, who knows how big the EMP was, and if they were affected by it.  But still, it does seem like a bit of a plot hole, doesn't it?

This made me laugh: "I can understand why Mary would complain loudly, but if she thinks the confiscation of 40 gallons of fuel was a violation of her civil rights, just wait until she meets the A.S.A."  But you've also got it right.  Mary's eyes will surely be opened in the future, won't they?  Honestly, it seemed weird to me that Mary would frankly br wasting gasoline on the generator to power the jukebox at the end of Vox Populi, and then come Heart of Winter and Eric's claiming they can't afford the gas to drive farther out to go hunting.  Also in Black Jack, Gray was already talking about rationing power to town hall and the med center.  So this was my attempt to reconcile the details of all those episodes.  :-)  As for Johnston's continued influence in town, it sure seemed to me that he had it, and well, I can't write a world where he's completely shut out. 

Okay, I really didn't think I was going to fool anyone with Jake and Heather waking up together, but I hadn't thought about it all being a dream!  That's too funny.  If I ever do write a scene where Jake is disgruntled to find himself waking up with Baron instead of Heather, you can claim that scene as your own.  :-)  I'm glad you enjoyed what I did go with.

Your take on the difference between Emily and Heather is quite interesting to me.  It's not exactly what I was thinking -- how I was thinking about it -- when I wrote it, but you're right, it's in there.  I just know that Heather, as an outsider, has to prove herself in a way that Emily doesn't.  I think Jake learned his lesson about marriage proposals.  (And for the rest on that I suggest reading Part 13B!) I look forward to finding out if you think that Jake got it right the second time around!

Thanks again for taking the time to review.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 08 Mar 2009 Title: Chapter 2: Part 13B

I enjoyed the contrast in this chapter.  There was the inherent sweetness of the proposal that made my little shipper heart go pitter-patter.   Then there was the tenseness of the road gang encounter that made my heart beat in a far different way.  While I knew how both encounters would end, I couldn't help but be drawn into them.  The details you provide make the characters and their situations so real, Marzee. 

Something else that I liked was the scene with Johnston and Gail.  Pride and the lack of communication have strained that father/son relationship, obviously, but it was good to see Gail trying to draw out some of the issues from her husband.

Nicely done!

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 05 Apr 2009 Title: Chapter 3: Part 13C

Another enjoyable installment, Marzee!  I really liked how you fleshed out the aftermath of the road gang incident.  I felt so bad for Mimi--scared for her, really, even though I knew how things would turn out.  To have gone through what they did, to be unfamiliar with a place, to be cold, to be worried about those she cared for...that really puts into perspective what her venturing out to get help was all about.  Then the scenes between Jake and Stanley back at the truck also held me riveted.   I also enjoyed the scenes with Stanley and Jake, with Stanley trying to keep Jake conscious.  I thought you did a really good job portraying their friendship and conveying Stanley's confusion over Jake's statements about the girl.

In the five years ago scenes, I thought we got to see a fascinating contradiction between the way that Jake's family reacted to the news of the engagement and the way that Heather's dad did.  It stands to reason that Gail and Johnston would be excited.  They have, after all, watched this romance unfold.  Logically, I don't blame Heather's dad for being concerned.  To him, I'm sure this would all seem very sudden.  On the other hand, there was that side of me that felt really bad for Heather.  Here she is with what is probably the best news of her entire life thus far, and her father isn't particularly happy for her. I thought Jake handled himself well with her dad, and I'm looking forward to reading about Jake meeting the Lisinskis.  How daunting that would be!  Of course, if anyone could handle it, it would be Jake.

Thanks for sharing your story with us.  I always get so excited when I see that you've updated it.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 10 May 2009 Title: Chapter 4: Part 13D

Hi Marzee,

Just wanted to say how much I enjoyed this latest installment of DC.  I have some specifics on which I want to comment, but I'm just running on empty right now.  I'll come back when I can string together some coherent thoughts.

Reviewer: SandraDee Signed
Date: 12 May 2009 Title: Chapter 4: Part 13D

Ah, I'm back. 

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I once again must comment on how masterfully you incorporate little details into your story that make the characters and their actions seem so real.  It was so easy for me to see the opening scene of this part play out in my mind, everything from April mouthing 'Jake' to Michael, the Cowboy Jake reference, to Mimi and Stanley's attempt to tell what happened without absolutely panicking Heather.  Later, the scene between Johnston and Jake was extremely touching.  I remember it being one of my favorite on the show, largely due to the emotion in Gerald McRaney's eyes and the way Skeet Ulrich's voice broke in the retelling.  Yet in reading your take on it, I felt like I got so much more in terms of nuances, as well as the urgency of their situation.  Heck, I almost felt cold reading your descriptions of the weather, and it's 80 degrees here!

The scene from five years earlier as word spreads to April and Eric about Jake and Heather's engagement provided a light hearted contrast to the present day scenes.  I still find myself sad for Eric and April, seeing how happy they were then and comparing that to the state of their marriage in the present. I'm definitely looking forward to Jake meeting the Lisinskis. 

Thanks for sharing your story with us.  I continue to enjoy it immensely.